New fossils shed light on the origin of ‘hobbits’


Griffith University researchers are part of an international team of scientists that has announcedthe discovery of ancestors of Homo floresiensis — the enigmatic species of pygmy-like humans
discovered more than a decade ago on the Indonesian island of Flores.

In September 2003, the partial skeleton of a primitive human adult female was excavated fromLiang Bua, a limestone cave in the west of Flores.

Known as LB1, this skeleton is the mostextreme human ever discovered — astonishingly short, only about a metre tall, and with a brainsmaller than that of a chimp, this tiny individual lived and died around 70,000 years ago.

Now, as reported in Nature this week, fossil remains of hominins that are similar in size but at leastten times older have been excavated at Mata Menge, a site in open grasslands 70 km east ofLiang Bua, in Indonesia.

A fragment of a hominin lower jaw and several isolated teeth were found in a layer of sandstone which had been deposited by a lakeside stream around 700,000 yearsago.

Breakthrough find

Dr Adam Brumm from Griffith’s Research Centre of Human Evolution says this new finding is themost stunning breakthrough yet to help with our understanding of the origin of ‘hobbits’.

“We have unearthed fossils from at least three individuals, including two children, along with stonetools that are almost identical to those made by the much younger Homo floresiensis,” said DrBrumm, an archaeologist who first commenced fieldwork at Mata Menge in 2004 along withcolleagues from the Geology Museum and Geological Survey Institute in Bandung, Indonesia.

“There is a striking similarity in size and form between the Mata Menge hominins and the LiangBua hobbit, which is surprising given the former are at least several hundred millennia older.

“This suggests the Mata Menge individuals belonged to a population of ancient hobbit-likehominins that gave rise to Homo floresiensis. They may even have been a very early form ofhobbits, which would mean this species existed for far longer than anyone had anticipated.”

Dr Adam Brumm, from Griffith University's Centre for Human Evolution
Dr Adam Brumm, from Griffith University’s Centre for Human Evolution


Ever since the first hobbit bones were discovered scientists have struggled to make sense ofwhere the previously unknown species, Homo floresiensis, fits into the human family tree.

It is thought that these creatures evolved from an archaic branch of hominins that existed longbefore the emergence of our own species in Africa some 200,000 years ago. However, the expertsare divided over just which member of the hominin group spawned the Flores hobbits.

Two hypotheses

The distinctive anatomy of Homo floresiensis has led to two intriguing hypotheses.

The first is thathobbits descend from Asian Homo erectus, or ‘Java Man’, an early hominin that reached theisland of Java to the west of Flores roughly 1.5 million years ago, and which was similar in heightto modern humans.

It is suggested a small group of these hominins may have become strandedon Flores and over time reduced in body size. This would be a unique case of homininsconforming to the ‘Island Rule’, whereby mammals cut off on islands with limited food and no predators become small if they were big (dwarfism) or big if they were small (gigantism).

The second possibility is that Homo floresiensis stems from far more ancient precursors, such asHomo habilis or even an ape-like australopithecine, primitive hominin forerunners currently knownonly from the early fossil record of Africa.

All of this speculation about the origin of Homo floresiensis had reached a standstill until thediscovery of these latest fossils.

“While only a handful of fossils has been found at Mata Menge so far, characteristic features of theteeth strongly imply an ancestral relationship with Homo erectus,” Dr Brumm said.

“This lends weight to the theory that the hobbit was a dwarfed version of the famous Java Man,which somehow got marooned on the island. The fact that they were found with fossils of extinctpygmy elephants (Stegodon) and giant rats also supports the idea of an isolated group of Homoerectus undergoing a dramatic evolutionary change owing to the Island Rule.”

Mata Menge excavations
Mata Menge excavations

Until more complete hominin fossils are revealed, however, Dr Brumm says the mystery of thehobbit’s beginning has not yet been conclusively resolved.

“We were expecting a simple answer,” he says.

“We didn’t get one: no one thought the ancestor ofthe hobbit would itself have looked like a hobbit. I do think Homo floresiensis was a dwarfed Homoerectus, but identifying the true ancestor requires more fossil evidence”.

The presence of fossils from multiple individuals at Mata Menge, however, does suggest additionalskeletal remains are likely to be found, and the team is now searching for funds to expand thescale of excavations at this site and at other fossil localities on the island.

“Mata Menge is a goldmine,” says Dr Brumm. “I expect that further excavations at this site willeventually yield a hominin skull, which will finally allow us to put a face and a name to the hobbit’sancestor. Then we will know how this experiment in human evolution got started”.


The Mata Menge research was funded by an Australian Research Council (ARC) Discovery grant(DP1093342), with support from the Geological Survey Institute of Bandung, Indonesia. Theexcavations are led by an Indonesian-Australian team from Bandung’s Geology Museum (GM),the Research Centre of Human Evolution (RCHE) at Griffith University, and the Centre forArchaeological Science (CAS) at the University of Wollongong.

Dr Adam Brumm, senior researchfellow at RCHE and head of its archaeology program, directed the fossil dig with Iwan Kurniawan(GM), Dr Gerrit van den Bergh (CAS) and the late Prof Mike Morwood (CAS). Radioisotopic datingof fossil teeth was undertaken by Prof Rainer Grün, Director of RCHE, and Dr Mathieu Duval, apostdoctoral researcher due to commence his ARC Future Fellowship at RCHE in late-2016.

Thehominin fossils were described by Japanese palaeoanthropologist Prof Yousuke Kaifu from theDepartment of Anthropology, National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo.

Established in 2016 as an initiative of Griffith University, and based within the EnvironmentalFutures Research Institute, RCHE is the first academic centre focused specifically on telling thestory of the evolutionary history of modern humans and archaic hominins in Southeast Asia andthe wider Australasian region.

Recent findings published by RCHE members include the discoveryon Sulawesi of some of the world’s oldest surviving rock art, and the revelation that homininsinhabited this Indonesian island prior to the arrival of Homo sapiens.